Indigo

Is there a case for Pakistan?
Imagining India

11/23/2010
MICA
PGP-17

board Members:
* Era Bali (Chairperson)
* Arvind Menon
* Mayank Prakash
* Druti Singh
* Priyanka Agarwal
* Anusha Azeez
* Namrata Bora
* Tarang Girdher
* Aakriti Goel
* Aditi Utpat
* Jayati Somani
* Ritika Garg
* Sania Narulkar
* Shrai Bhandula
* Suhail Kapur

Is there a case for Pakistan?
Structure of the interchange:
* What is the necessary and sufficient condition for a nation to personify?
* Is Nation a contiguous stretch of territory controlled by a single state or divided on the basis of religion, language, race or ethnicity?

Points Discussed:
* Nationality is a social tincture: A tactual sensation of sentiment of oneness which makes those associated with it kith and kin
* Also, seen an anti syndicate feeling for those who arent a part of ones own social group
* 2 offend perspectives were, one in favor of having a separate and an obvious case for Pakistan and the new(prenominal) as Muslims being a part of the common state.




Points against were:
* overlap a common environment
* Union through language
* Long ago relationships of sacrifices, efforts, social capital and to have done great things together
* normal matters of pride and achievement
Points for were:
* Divide on the basis of political and ghostly antagonisms

* The opinion in favor of creating Pakistan as a separate Muslim state were:
* Common environment, language etc. were dilettantish facts that did not really bind the Hindus and Muslims.
* Muslims still felt a sense of oneness within their community, a sense that did not extent to other communities
* There was no sense of shared out history or conquests, necessary to create a feeling of oneness
-------------------------------------------------

* Reasons why hindus always claimed India to be a nation
* Indians were struggle against a...If you want to get a full essay, order it on our website: Ordercustompaper.com



If you want to get a full essay, wisit our page: write my paper